A Differentiated Short Story Unit That Keeps Whole-Class Discussion Together (3 Text Levels)

A differentiated short story unit for middle school shouldn’t require three separate lesson plans. This approach keeps pacing and discussion unified by offering three aligned text versions (Accessible/HILO, Leveled, Original) while students complete the same discussion questions and the same exit quiz routine.

Preview the exact structure in a free download:
FREE: The Yellow Wallpaper Differentiated Study Guide

Save 40% on the full set of 15 differentiated short stories:
Women Writers Short Stories Bundle (15 Differentiated Study Guides)

The “one routine, three texts” model

  • Students read the version that supports comprehension today (Accessible/HILO, Leveled, or Original)
  • Whole-class discussion stays unified with shared prompts
  • Assessment stays consistent with an aligned exit quiz
  • Extension is built in with vocabulary, short-answer, and challenge questions

Teacher prep checklist (5 minutes)

  • Choose the story and decide: 1 day or 2 days
  • Decide who reads Accessible/HILO, Leveled, or Original
  • Pick 4–6 discussion questions you know you’ll use
  • Plan the exit quiz moment (end of class or next day)

How to assign the 3 text levels (without stigma)

  • Option A (quiet differentiation): Give each group a “Version A / Version B / Version C” label rather than reading-level labels.
  • Option B (choice with guardrails): Students choose, but you reserve the right to switch them after Day 1 based on participation and comprehension.
  • Option C (station rotation): Start with Accessible/HILO for everyone to build baseline comprehension, then offer Leveled/Original for extension readers.

Two pacing options you can reuse all year

Option 1: One-day mini-unit (45–60 minutes)

  • Read (15–25 min)
  • Discussion Questions (10–15 min)
  • Exit Quiz (8–12 min)
  • Finishers: 2–3 vocabulary words + 1 challenge question

Option 2: Two-day mini-unit (best for denser stories)

  • Day 1: Read + Discussion Questions + short-answer check
  • Day 2: Finish reading + Discussion Questions + Exit Quiz

A discussion routine that forces text evidence (and works across versions)

Use this simple protocol so “discussion” doesn’t become opinion-only:

  1. Claim: Students answer the question in one sentence.
  2. Detail: Students point to one specific detail from their assigned text version.
  3. Explain: Students explain how the detail supports the claim.

Sentence frames (helpful for mixed readers):

  • “In the text, the character/narrator ___, which shows ___.”
  • “This detail matters because it connects to the theme of ___.”

Stories that work especially well with this model (click to preview)

What’s included (per title)

Each story includes three aligned text versions, student materials (vocabulary, short-answer, challenge questions), a multiple-choice exit quiz, and teacher materials (discussion questions, answer keys, and a self-graded quiz option). The free sample above shows the exact format.

Conversion-friendly “next step” (for teachers who want consistency)

If you like the routine, the bundle is designed so you can reuse the same structure across 15 classic stories by top women writers:

Women Writers Short Stories Bundle (Save 40%)

Frequently Asked Questions

Do students have to read the same version to discuss together?

No. The discussion questions and exit quiz are designed to work across versions, so students can participate with evidence from their assigned text.

What if a student “chooses too easy”?

Start with choice, then adjust after Day 1 based on discussion participation and exit quiz results. The goal is comprehension first, then extension.

Can I use this format for intervention groups?

Yes. Many teachers use the Accessible/HILO version for guided reading and then scale up to Leveled or Original for growth and quoting practice.

Back to blog